Toronto II - Columbus Crew 2

	1 - 2 (1 - 3 p.)
Toronto II	05.05.2024 22:00 Ended after a penalty shootout	Columbus Crew 2

1st half
16'	H. Ayari	1 - 0
2nd half
			49'	J. Knight
		1 - 1	52'	Cole Mrowka (O. Presthus)
87'	Antony CuricAdam Pearlman
89'	N. Edwards
Extra time
		1 - 2
Penalty shootout
1'	J. Altobelli	1 - 0
		1 - 1	1'	C. Adams
2'	M. Catavolo
		1 - 2	2'	O. Presthus
3'	Markus Cimermancic
		1 - 3	3'	T. Habroune
4'	C. Staniland